상세검색
최근 검색어 전체 삭제
다국어입력
즐겨찾기0
147762.jpg
KCI등재 학술저널

‘Mediation’과 ‘Conciliation’의 개념에 관한 비교법적 연구

A Comparative Study on the Concepts of Mediation and Conciliation

  • 55

Concepts of mediation and conciliation as alternative dispute resolutions are often confusingly used. As to what is meant by mediation and conciliation, there is no uniform legal definition. However, there has been a distinction between two methods of dispute settlement under the international law (UN Charter, WTO DSU, NAFTA, EU mediation directive, WIPO Mediation Rules) although there is no clear definition on the terms of mediation and conciliation. And also under the domestic law such as U.K, France, Germany, a clear distinction has been made between two terms. Mediation means a facilitated negotiation between two parties through the intervention of a third party. A third and neutral party (mediator) help the parties in dispute to find their solution by managing a certain mediation protocol and facilitating communication between the parties while in conciliation, a third party evaluative the case and can suggest the parties a legally non-binding solution. Once the parties accept it, it becomes binding between them. However, in the U.S,, it seems that there is no practical use of distinguishing mediation and conciliation. The term of mediation is more commonly used than the term of conciliation and it has two kinds of mediation such as facilitative and evaluative mediation. Korea’s conciliation system is close to conciliation or evaluative mediation. In conclusion, what is distinct between mediation and conciliation is the role of third party. If a neutral third party takes a role of advisor or facilitator, then he or she may employ a proper protocol to help the parties to find themselves their solution (mediation) while if a neutral person plays a role of evaluator, then he or she listens to the parties and suggest a solution to them (conciliation).

Ⅰ. 서론

Ⅱ. 국제법상 Mediation과 Conciliation

Ⅲ. 국내법상 Mediation과 Conciliation

Ⅳ. Mediation과 Conciliation의 비교

Ⅴ. 결론

참고문헌

ABSTRACT

로딩중