The Dilemma and Solution of Judicial Review of Explanatory Administrative Rules

解释性行政规则司法审查的困境与出路

초록

With the deepening of administrative rule of law construction, explanatory administrative rules play an increasingly important role in administrative management. However, the issue of its legality and rationality has attracted social attention, especially in the process of judicial review, which faces challenges such as conflicts between judicial review and administrative professionalism, unclear review standards, and a lack of review intensity system. By drawing on international experience and comparative analysis, as well as some case studies, optimization suggestions have been proposed for administrative agencies to explain procedures, improve judicial review standards, and construct a judicial review intensity system. Ensure a balance between judicial review, administrative efficiency, and legal protection, and promote the stability and transparency of the administrative legal system.

随着行政法治建设的深化，解释性行政规则在行政管理中发挥着越来越重要的作用。然而，其合法性和合理性问题引发了社会关注，特别是在司法审查过程中，面临司法审查与行政专业性冲突、审查标准不明确以及审查强度体系缺失等困境。通过借鉴国际经验比较分析以及一些案例研究，提出了行政机关的解释说明程序、完善司法审查标准和构建司法审查强度体系等优化建议。确保司法审查与行政效率、法治保障之间的平衡，推动行政法治体系的稳定与透明。